17 Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Tucson, AZ

Searching for the best car insurance agency in Tucson, AZ can be overwhelming. With so many options, it can be hard to know which one is the best for you. That’s why we’ve rounded up the top 17 local car insurance agencies in Tucson, AZ. From coverage options to customer service, we’ll help you find the agency that fits your needs. Keep reading to learn more about the best car insurance agencies in Tucson, AZ.

Stratton Everything Insurance

Stratton Everything Insurance is an independent brokerage serving clients in Tucson. It offers car insurance policies that protect owners against legal and medical expenses resulting from property damage, loss of life, and injuries in the aftermath of accidents, disasters, or theft. The brokerage compares auto, home, health, and life insurance coverage options from a variety of insurance carriers to meet clients’ individual needs. For its logo, it adopted a Greek symbol, which stands for summation, to depict its status as a full-service brokerage.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.everythinginsure.com/

Phone: +1 520-771-0222

Full Address: 2102 N Country Club Rd #9, Tucson, AZ 85716

Get Directions

Frontier Insurance Concepts

Frontier Insurance Concepts is an independent agency that helps clients in Tucson. It offers auto insurance policies for standard and antique cars. The agency files each policy to include coverage for collision damage and vandalism. It also provides security for emergencies and natural disasters, such as fires and flooding. Aside from repairs, the agency customizes policies to include temporary rental and roadside assistance. Frontier Insurance Concepts examines different policy plans from recognized carriers, including Hagerty and Safeco.

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://frontieragents.com/

Phone: +1 520-818-2300

Full Address: 7470 N La Cholla Blvd, Tucson, AZ 85741

Get Directions

Mooney Insurance

Founded in 1995, Mooney Insurance is an independent insurance agency located in Tucson, Arizona. Auto coverage specialists work with over 1 carriers to help drivers get quality plans at fair rates. Options include the state minimum amount of liability insurance with the choice of collision and comprehensive policies that cover damage from accidents, theft, weather events, and vandalism, and bodily injury, property damage, and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. Clients can seek multi-car, good drivers, and good student discounts.

Rating: 4.6

Website : http://mooneyagency.com

Phone: +1 520-751-0502

Full Address: 10501 E Seven Generations Way Ste 201-08, Tucson, AZ 85747

Get Directions


Insurely is an independent insurance agency that serves individuals and families from Tucson and the surrounding areas. It offers automobile insurance policies with coverage options such as comprehensive, collision, bodily injury liability, and property damage liability. Other types of insurance products that it provides include homeowners’ and life insurance. The company is partnered with over 5 insurance carriers, including Foremost, Nationwide, Liberty Mutual, and Travelers. Insurely has been in operation for more than six years.

Rating: nan

Website : https://www.myinsurely.com/

Phone: +1 520-355-3200

Full Address: 510 N 7th Ave, Tucson, AZ 85705

Get Directions

Blake Insurance Group

Blake Insurance Group LLC is an independent insurance agency in Tuscon, Arizona. It offers a variety of auto insurance solutions, including boat, RV, and motorcycle insurance. Standard auto insurance plans include bodily injury and property damage liability, and customers have the opportunity to customize their policy to include additional coverage options, such as collision, comprehensive, and medical payments insurance. Blake Insurance Group LLC also offers homeowners, commercial, and medical insurance policies.

Rating: 5.0

Website : http://blakeinsurancegroup.com

Phone: +1 520-402-6002

Full Address: 5151 E Broadway Blvd Suite 1600, Tucson, AZ 85711

Get Directions

Polder Insurance

In business for over a decade, Polder Insurance assists clients within the Tucson, Arizona, metro area with auto insurance policies. It educates clients on legally required and optional coverage areas and guides them through the process of shopping for rates as they explore agreements with associated providers. Typically agents help clients to secure coverage agreements for property damage, personal and vicarious liability, and comprehensive circumstances. Polder Insurance provides home insurance services as well.

Rating: 4.9

Website : http://polderinsurance.com

Phone: +1 520-370-3230

Full Address: 2500 N Pantano Rd STE 130, Tucson, AZ 85715

Get Directions

The Insurance House Tucson

The Insurance House Tucson has been offering insurance policies to clients in the metro since 1963. Its car insurance covers damage from road accidents and medical costs for injured passengers. The policy also compensates vehicle owners for vandalism and theft. The firm insures vehicles such as boats and motorcycles, homes, condos, and rental properties. Businesses can get policies to cover vehicle fleets and workers’ compensation claims. Founder Milton Silverman has more than 5 years of industry experience.

Rating: 4.5

Website : https://www.theinsurancehousetucson.com/

Phone: +1 520-795-7737

Full Address: 2801 E Broadway Blvd, Tucson, AZ 85716

Get Directions

Tucson Business Insurance

Tucson Business Insurance caters to clients in the metro and the surrounding communities. It offers auto insurance policies, helping drivers protect themselves while on the road. Also included in its line of products are home, health, life, personal umbrella, professional liability, and workers’ compensation insurance plans. The agency partners with various companies, such as Foremost, Kemper, Liberty Mutual, The Hartford, and Travelers. Stevie Hopkins, its owner, has been working in the industry since 212.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://tucins.com/

Phone: +1 520-413-3000

Full Address: 2910 N Swan Rd #205, Tucson, AZ 85712

Get Directions

Paul Barker Agency – American Family Insurance

The Paul Barker Agency with American Family Insurance is a locally operated agency helping clients throughout the Tucson, Arizona, metro area with auto insurance. Founder Paul Barker has over 15 years of experience in insurance and his agents assist with collision and comprehensive coverage, as well as property damage and bodily injury liability. This agency frequently works with teen drivers and offers umbrella policies for clients who wish to combine auto insurance with home coverage and other policies.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://paulbarkeragency.com

Phone: +1 520-877-8133

Full Address: 8275 N Silverbell Rd STE 130, Tucson, AZ 85743

Get Directions

Alvarez Insurance

Since 1987, Alvarez Insurance has been catering to individuals and businesses in Tucson. Its team offers various policies to car owners that can compensate them following road crashes. The firm’s auto insurance covers injuries, vehicle repairs, and damage caused by uninsured drivers. Clients can also get policies for their homes and rental properties and commercial insurance for vehicle fleets and workers’ compensation. Alvarez Insurance is a family-owned agency that is managed by Ruth Anne Matheson.

Rating: 4.6

Website : http://www.segurosalvarezinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 520-269-6822

Full Address: 4733 S 12th Ave, Tucson, AZ 85714

Get Directions

Tucson Insurance

Tucson Insurance was founded in 199 and is based in Tucson, Arizona. It offers auto insurance policies via a network of prominent providers. Policies include coverage for vehicle loss or damage, medical bills, costs incurred via accidents involving uninsured motorists, bodily injury liability, and property damage liability. There are optional riders for rental car reimbursement, roadside recovery, vandalism, and extreme weather. Tucson Insurance also offers home, motorcycle, and term life insurance.

Rating: 5.0

Website : http://tucsoninsurance.com

Phone: +1 520-797-9900

Full Address: 1610 N Kolb Rd, Tucson, AZ 85715

Get Directions

Brown Insurance Agency

Founded in 1999, Brown Insurance Agency is an independent firm that caters to the needs of clients in Tucson and its surrounding areas. Its team of professionals offers a wide variety of products, including car, home, and life insurance. The business also provides workers’ compensation policies. Brown Insurance Agency works with more than 3 insurance companies, such as MetLife, Safeco, Hartford, and Progressive. Its president, Kevin Brown, has more than three decades’ worth of industry experience.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://browninsured.com/

Phone: +1 520-888-6900

Full Address: 3275 W Ina Rd #111, Tucson, AZ 85741

Get Directions

Haslett & Assoc. Insurance

Located in Tuscon, Arizona, independent insurance agency Haslett & Assoc. Insurance has been protecting drivers of the metro area for more than four decades. Its auto insurance policies are customized to clients’ concerns and budget with most policies including a variety of coverages such as liability, property damage, and comprehensive. Motorcycles and recreational vehicles are just as welcome as cars and trucks. Haslett and Assoc. Insurance also offers life, business, and homeowners insurance.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://haslettins.com

Phone: +1 520-327-6504

Full Address: 8375 N Oracle Rd #100, Oro Valley, AZ 85704

Get Directions

ABC Insurance

ABC Insurance, located in Tucson, Arizona, strives to match motorists in the greater Tucson area with auto insurance policies that meet their needs. Serving the Southern Arizona and Tucson communities from its two locations since 1998, this independent insurance agency works with many top national insurance carriers to help drivers get the coverage they need at competitive prices, including policies ranging from general liability and bodily injury to collision and comprehensive coverage.

Rating: 4.8

Website : http://insurewithabc.com

Phone: +1 520-294-5900

Full Address: 743 W Irvington Rd, Tucson, AZ 85714

Get Directions

Mike Pierce Insurance

Mike Pierce Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Tucson, Arizona, with over 42 years of experience and three area locations to serve drivers. Policy specialists work with several top carriers, including Dairyland Auto, Progressive, and Kemper Specialty, to find clients the best possible coverage at competitive rates. The company also offers motorcycle, ATV, boats, RV insurance, homeowners, renters, and mobile home insurance, and provides services in English and Spanish.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://mikepierceinsurance.com

Phone: +1 520-584-9000

Full Address: 6545 E 22nd St, Tucson, AZ 85711

Get Directions

One Call Insurance

One Call Insurance is an independent broker based in the city of Tucson. Since 23, it has been assisting clients in preparing themselves for unexpected changes and events in life by offering business and personal insurance products, including auto and home. The auto insurance plan covers clients’ vehicle damage repairs. Its bilingual staff helps clients get the right insurance policies and guides them throughout the process. One Call Insurance has served over 3, clients in the area.

Rating: 4.5

Website : https://one-call-insurance.business.site/

Phone: +1 520-887-7777

Full Address: 7259 E Golf Links Rd, Tucson, AZ 85730

Get Directions

Simple Insurance of Arizona, LLC

Simple Insurance of Arizona LLC is an independent insurance agency that serves the Tuscon metropolitan area as a provider of auto insurance and other insurance products. Founded in 211, the agency provides auto coverage that includes protection against liability as well as damage to the vehicle. The company also writes auto insurance policies for those traveling to Mexico. Simple Insurance of Arizona shops for the best coverage at the best price through over 5 carriers.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://simple-az.com

Phone: +1 520-308-5202

Full Address: 3275 W Ina Rd Ste 165, Tucson, AZ 85741

Get Directions

Popular Posts