22 Best Homeowners Insurance Agencies in Boston, MA

Boston is a great city for homeowners looking for the perfect insurance policy. With so many insurance agencies to choose from, it can be hard to find the best one. That’s why we’ve done the research to bring you the top 22 homeowners insurance agencies in the Boston area. Whether you’re looking for the best coverage, the most competitive rates, or the most comprehensive policies, you’ll find what you need in this list. So, let’s dive in and find the best homeowners insurance policy for your Boston home.

LoPriore Insurance Agency

Founded in 1995, LoPriore Insurance Agency is an independent insurance company located in Stoneham, Massachusetts, and serving renters and homeowners in the Boston metro area. LoPriore works with a variety of carriers, including American Modern, The Hartford, Progressive, and Travelers. The agency offers home insurance solutions for a variety of dwelling types, including single and multifamily homes, condos, and rental properties, for homeowners as well as renters. The personal property coverage included in homeowners policies affords worldwide protection.

Rating: 5.0

Website : http://lopriore.com

Phone: +1 781-438-1375

Full Address: 426 Main St Suite 2, Stoneham, MA 02180

Get Directions

Claremont Insurance Agency Inc.

Claremont Insurance Agency, Inc., provides insurance services for clients in Boston and the surrounding communities. This family-owned company provides various types of insurance plans, including homeowners’ insurance, renters’ insurance, and condominium insurance. It also provides fire, flood safety, and jewelry and fine art insurance policies. This woman-operated agency has been serving clients since 1939. Saverio Paventi, company founder, initially established the firm in East Boston. Today, the multi-generational insurance agency is located in Revere.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://claremontins.com/

Phone: +1 781-289-6700

Full Address: 319 Broadway, Revere, MA 02151

Get Directions

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Plymouth Rock Assurance has been providing insurance coverage to clients in Boston for over 35 years. It offers a wide range of products to residential clients, including homeowners’ and renters’ insurance. These insurance policies are designed to provide coverage for policyholders’ homes, as well as additional structures and personal items. The agency allows clients to customize their policies by adding Home Cyber, Home Systems Breakdown, Utility Service Line, and Identity Protection. Its other products include auto, umbrella, pets, and life insurance.

Rating: 4.0

Website : https://www.plymouthrock.com/

Phone: +1 617-951-1620

Full Address: nan

Get Directions

Warren Insurance Agency

Warren Insurance Agency is a family-owned agency that serves clients in the Boston area. It provides an array of homeowners’ insurance policies to help policyholders protect their homes and personal belongings from catastrophes such as fire, windstorms and hail, theft, and falling objects. It also provides risk protection plans for life, business properties, and automobiles. The agency has been in operation since 1979. It is committed to helping customers navigate through their insurance options and understand the outcome of their chosen policies.

Rating: 4.6

Website : https://warreninsuranceagency.com/

Phone: +1 617-265-1414

Full Address: 764 Blue Hill Avenue, Dorchester, MA 02124

Get Directions

John M. Biggio Insurance

Established in 1958, John M. Biggio Insurance is a risk management specialist that serves the Boston area. Its range of products includes homeowners’ insurance, which covers detached structures such as decks and garages along with personal property, including clothing, furniture, and appliances. Its team of underwriters also furnishes insurance plans that protect renters and condominium owners. Company CEO John E. Biggio has been insuring clients for over 25 years. He specializes in providing coverage for artisans, nonprofits, and contractors.

Rating: 4.6

Website : https://biggioinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 617-846-8600

Full Address: 399 Winthrop St, Winthrop, MA 02152

Get Directions

Spataro & Bellino Insurance

Spataro & Bellino Insurance serves clients in Boston and the surrounding areas. The company caters to both individual and commercial clients who need insurance policies such as homeowners’, auto, commercial auto, and small business insurance. The agency has more than three decades of experience in insurance claims. Spataro & Bellino Insurance was formerly known as Pace Insurance, which was founded in 1933. Richard Spataro, the current owner of the company, has more than 25 years of experience in marketing, underwriting, claims, and accounting.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://spataroinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 617-567-6558

Full Address: 156 Maverick St, East Boston, MA 02128

Get Directions

Lattanzi Insurance Agency

Founded in 1974, Lattanzi Insurance Agency is an independent company serving the Boston metro. It offers homeowners’ insurance plans that include theft protection, water backup failure, and dwelling and content replacement cost coverages. The agency also serves clients who want to acquire life, health, classic car, and pet insurance. Its team also works with various insurance carriers, such as Travelers, American Modern, and Banner Life. Lattanzi Insurance Agency is a member of the National Association of Professional Insurance Agents.

Rating: 5.0

Website : http://lattanziinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 781-284-8783

Full Address: 166 Winthrop Ave, Revere, MA 02151

Get Directions

Robert T. Fowler & Sons Insurance Company

Robert T. Fowler & Sons Insurance Company is an independent agency located in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts. It has served the Boston area since 195. Owner Stephen Fowler has over 25 years of experience providing homeowners policy coverage and knowledgeable customer service to clients. The firm works with each client to customize coverage needs. Policies include liability coverage and protection against damage to personal property within the home. Robert T. Fowler & Sons Insurance Company also offers auto, flood, and renters insurance.

Rating: 5.0

Website : http://trustthisbiz.com/robert_t_fowler__sons_insurance

Phone: +1 617-524-0500

Full Address: 743 Centre St, Jamaica Plain, MA 02130

Get Directions

Metro South Insurance

Metro South Insurance is a full-service brokerage that offers risk management assistance in Boston. Included in its product line is home insurance which includes liability protection and medical expenses coverage. It also reimburses losses in cases of theft or vandalism. In addition, the independent agency provides protection plans for renters, drivers, and business owners. Metro South Insurance, which was founded in 23, is also licensed in New Hampshire and Rhode Island. Its staff members speak English, Vietnamese, and Spanish.

Rating: 4.5

Website : https://metrosouthinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 617-287-8888

Full Address: 835 Dorchester Ave, Dorchester, MA 02125

Get Directions

D’Attilio Insurance Agency

D’Attilio Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Dedham, serving the Greater Boston area of Massachusetts and beyond. Founded in 1956, its aim is to act as a trusted advisor to its clients. The agency represents multiple insurance carriers, including Travelers and N&D, finding and shaping the most suitable home insurance coverage for its customers. It ensures basic coverage forms part of the policy and optional extras such as water back-up/sump overflow and earthquake/earth movement are included if appropriate.

Rating: 4.4

Website : http://dattilioins.com

Phone: +1 781-326-8830

Full Address: 347 Washington St, Dedham, MA 02026

Get Directions

Derek Witham Insurance Agency, Inc.

Derek Witham Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent insurance agency offering insurance policies to families, individuals, and businesses in and around Boston since 1996. Its agents have access to an extensive network of homeowners insurance carriers that offer comprehensive and personalized coverage for structural and personal property damage, loss of use, natural disasters, and premises liability. The agency also offers other insurance products such as auto, commercial vehicles, personal umbrellas, and business insurance.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.withaminsurance.com/

Phone: +1 781-322-2886

Full Address: 269 Broadway, Malden, MA 02148

Get Directions

Kaplansky Insurance

Kaplansky Insurance is an independent agency serving residents across Brookline, Massachusetts, since 1974. The company’s agents help buyers enroll in policies to protect their homes from possible risks. Its homeowners insurance covers damages and loss of contents caused by unexpected events, including theft, fire, and liabilities such as medical expenses for injuries sustained by guests. Other policies available at Kaplansky Insurance include auto, renters, umbrella, and condo insurance for both individuals and businesses.

Rating: 4.2

Website : http://kaplansky.com

Phone: +1 617-738-5400

Full Address: 114 Harvard St, Brookline, MA 02446

Get Directions


Openly is a Boston-based insurance firm that serves clients all across the city. Its homeowners’ policy covers the property’s construction, including the walls, roofs, and associated fixtures. It includes replacement cost coverage, open perils contents coverage, and high water backup limits. The agency also offers optional special endorsements, such as personal cyber, equipment breakdown, and home-sharing. Prior to establishing Openly in 217, Ty Harris spent 12 years as the EVP and chief product officer of a global insurer.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://openly.com/

Phone: +1 857-990-9080

Full Address: 131 Dartmouth St, Boston, MA 02116

Get Directions

Downey Insurance Agency

The Downey Insurance Agency is based in Marlborough, Massachusetts, providing insurance services throughout the Boston area. Founded in 1928, Home insurance is one of the many specialist services it provides. The agency represents a range of carriers, giving it the flexibility to identify and shape the right policies for its clients. Its packages can include protection for the physical structure of the home, its contents, living expenses if temporary accommodation is needed, and personal liability if a visitor is injured.

Rating: 4.1

Website : http://downeyinsurance.com

Phone: +1 508-485-0130

Full Address: 190 E Main St, Marlborough, MA 01752

Get Directions

Beacon Hill

Beacon Hill strives to simplify the insurance process for Boston consumers. The agency works with multiple insurance carriers to help clients find coverage options that match their personal or business needs. Some of the insurance products it offers include homeowners’ insurance, auto insurance, jewelry insurance, and motorcycle insurance. An online portal is accessible to clients, allowing them to easily manage their insurance policies, from ID card requests and bill payments to claim reports and policy changes.

Rating: nan

Website : https://beaconhillinsured.com/

Phone: nan

Full Address: Boston, MA

Get Directions

David E. Zeller Insurance Agency, Inc.

Based in Lynn, Massachusetts, David E. Zeller Insurance Agency Inc. is an independent specializing in home insurance, serving the Greater Boston area. Founded in 1978, it’s access to over 4 nationally recognized insurance carriers provides it with the means to find the best solutions for its clients. The core of its homeowner policies includes liability insurance, protection if someone is injured on the client’s property, as well as personal belongings and structure to reimburse the client if the worst happens.

Rating: 4.8

Website : http://davidzeller.com

Phone: +1 781-595-2071

Full Address: 370 Lynnway, Lynn, MA 01901

Get Directions

State Fund Insurance

State Fund Insurance is an agency that serves clients in the Boston area. It provides a variety of homeowners’ insurance policies to help customers protect their homes and properties from loss caused by fire and vandalism. It also offers risk protection plans for renters, commercial properties, condos, and motorcycles. Its agents can work with policyholders electronically via fax, e-mail, or phone. It works with insurance companies such as Safeco Insurance, Brownstone Agency, Inc., and Foremost Insurance Group.

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://www.statefundins.com/

Phone: +1 617-956-9999

Full Address: 100 Summer Street Suite 1601, Boston, MA 02110

Get Directions

Boynton Insurance Agency

Boynton Insurance Agency in Needham Heights, Massachusetts, is family-owned and operated and offers a full range of home insurance products. Established in 1919, this independent insurance agency also has offices in Easton and Georgetown to service the needs of homeowners throughout Eastern Massachusetts. It partners with more than 1 A-rated insurance carriers to give clients a broad choice when it comes to coverage options and offers expert advice to help its customers fully understand their insurance needs.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://boyntonins.com

Phone: +1 781-449-6786

Full Address: 72 River Park St #103, Needham Heights, MA 02494

Get Directions

Ann M. Foley Insurance Agency Inc.

Ann M. Foley Insurance Agency Inc. is a family-owned business serving clients in Boston since 1979. It offers homeowners’ insurance policies that protect clients’ homes and belongings from vandalism, home invasions, and weather damage. Clients can choose from an array of insurance policies that include family liability protection, guest medical protection, and personal property. Ann M. Foley Insurance Agency also offers insurance products that generate confidence for workers, contractors, and manufacturers.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.annfoleyinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 714-597-8554

Full Address: 1431 E Chapman Ave, Orange, CA 92866

Get Directions

Tonry Insurance Group

Tonry Insurance Group, Inc., assists individuals in securing home insurance in Boston. The service provider supports homeowners’ efforts in minimizing or avoiding costs from incidents like burglary, fire accidents, and personal liability. The business’s principals, Carl Traina and Louis “Lou” A. Tonry, Jr., have Massachusetts insurance licenses in property and casualty, life, and accident and health. Tonry Insurance Group, Inc., has offices in Quince and Lexington and has been in business since 1926.

Rating: 4.7

Website : http://www.tonry.com/

Phone: +1 617-773-9200

Full Address: 150 Grossman Dr Suite 200, Braintree, MA 02184

Get Directions

Pella Insurance Agency Inc

Pella Insurance Agency Inc. offers homeowners’ insurance for clients in Boston to protect their homes and valuables. As an independent insurance agency, it represents multiple insurance carriers that include Chubb, Safety Insurance, and Plymouth Rock. Paula Papadimitriou, the owner and president, has more than 3 years of insurance industry experience. She leads a group of insurance agents who live and work in the metro area, making them knowledgeable of the insurance needs of local residents.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.pellainsurance.com/

Phone: +1 617-787-0617

Full Address: 585 Washington St # A, Brighton, MA 02135

Get Directions

Bender Hatch Insurance

Bender Hatch Insurance addresses the needs of clients in Boston. It recognizes the importance of protecting clients’ properties and helps them by providing homeowners’ insurance coverage. The policy covers the estate against interior and exterior damage, premises liability, and loss of personal assets. The company also offers options for auto, condo, life, and business insurance. To give back to the community, Bender Hatch Insurance supports local businesses and the local healthcare heroes.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://benderhatch.com/

Phone: +1 617-367-4900

Full Address: 31 Milk St, Boston, MA 02109

Get Directions

Popular Posts